Consumer Behavior

In the hesitation economy, brand loyalty is no longer guaranteed

The U.S. economy has shown some resilience but consumer confidence has not kept pace. Shoppers are still spending, but they are spending differently: more deliberately, more comparatively and with less attachment to brands they once returned to by default.

Generated by AI/Adobe Stock

July 30, 2026 by Jaysen Gillespie — VP of Global Product Commercialization, RTB House

Summarize withChatGPTGrokPerplexityClaude

Nearly 60% of consumers now report switching brands — not out of dissatisfaction, but in search of better timing, pricing, or promotions. For retailers built on an assumption of habitual loyalty, that number should prompt a rethink.

The macroeconomic backdrop helps explain why. With GDP showing modest growth (1.6% in Q1 2026), the U.S. economy has shown some resilience — but consumer confidence has not kept pace. Shoppers are still spending, but they are spending differently: more deliberately, more comparatively and with less attachment to brands they once returned to by default.

In 2026, shoppers' mindsets are being shaped less by habit and more by caution. This is the defining characteristic of what many now call the "hesitation economy," a market environment in which activity continues but consumer confidence remains uncertain and highly reactive.

For retailers and brands, this creates a different competitive challenge from the one many have become used to during periods of stronger consumer confidence. Modern consumers are actively searching for reasons to switch brands.

However, reducing this trend to pure price sensitivity overlooks a broader shift.

The opportunistic consumer

It would be easy to assume, given a persistent cost-of-living crisis, that consumers are switching brands primarily on price, but this is not always the case. They are actually reassessing the value, timing, and necessity of every purchase they make. The traditional model of habitual buying, where consumers repeatedly return to familiar retailers or brands out of convenience or trust, is beginning to erode.

In its place is a more opportunistic form of shopping behavior. Today's consumers are far more likely to pause before purchasing, compare alternatives, revisit products multiple times and defer decisions until they feel certain they are getting the best possible outcome. Shopping journeys are becoming longer, less predictable and increasingly fragmented across devices and platforms.

As a result, brands can no longer treat loyalty as a permanent state. It must be re-earned continuously.

A matter of timing

This shift is especially pronounced among younger consumers. Research shows 50% of Gen Z shoppers require two or more days of "in-cart dwell time" before completing a purchase, compared with only 25% of Baby Boomers.

The gap highlights a growing generational divide in how purchasing decisions are made.

Younger consumers spend more time evaluating and consuming content before committing. In practical terms, that means the marketing window has expanded alongside the research window. For brands, remaining visible throughout that extended journey has become critical.

Retailers have traditionally focused on identifying which consumers match their target demographics — the right age, the right interests, the right purchase history. That question still matters, but in the hesitation economy, it is no longer sufficient on its own. Understanding when a specific consumer is most open to a decision has become equally important, and in many cases more so.

Not every moment in the customer journey carries equal weight. There are specific moments when indecision peaks, uncertainty increases, and consumers become more open to switching brands or reconsidering decisions. The marketers who can identify and act on those moments gain a significant advantage.

The challenge is that traditional audience segmentation — however sophisticated — is a tool built for answering who. Timing requires a different question and a different approach.

Signals, not segments

Identifying those moments is achievable, but it requires marketers to look beyond traditional tools — specifically to AI and deep learning for real-time behavioral analysis. Rather than relying solely on static audience segments, these technologies can interpret thousands of signals in real time to understand evolving purchase intent.

That includes browsing patterns, product comparisons, cart abandonment, repeat visits and timing signals indicating when a consumer may be reconsidering a purchase. The better a brand understands these moments of hesitation, the better positioned it is to influence outcomes.

For example, a consumer revisiting a product page multiple times over several days may not need another discount message; they may need reassurance about quality, delivery or product suitability. Another shopper may become vulnerable to competitor influence immediately after abandoning a cart. Others may simply need a timely reminder during a key consideration phase. In each case, the response is different. But the brands that get it right share one thing: They read the signal before acting on it. Brands that can deliver relevant messaging at exactly the prime moment are far more likely to intercept potential switching behavior before competitors do.

Understanding hesitation

Retailers cannot discount their way to lasting loyalty in an environment where consumers are constantly reassessing value. Long-term success requires a change in how brands communicate throughout the customer journey. This means recognizing that shoppers are no longer following neat purchasing patterns or linear funnels. Instead, they are moving fluidly between inspiration, research, hesitation, and purchase over an extended period.

Importantly, this is not simply about deploying more AI or automation. The technology is the enabler. The insight is human. Specifically, brands should identify the emotional and practical triggers behind modern purchase decisions and the factors that delay them. A consumer who pauses, revisits, and reconsiders has not walked away — they are still deciding. Indecision is not resistance. It is an opening.

The hesitation economy may not be a temporary condition. If consumer confidence remains reactive, then prolonged consideration and fluid loyalty could become permanent features of retail. The brands that build for that reality now, rather than waiting for confidence to return, will be the ones that continue to reach their consumers and define what loyalty looks like next.

About Jaysen Gillespie

---